Coupa is a company of talkers, passionate about sharing tips, tricks and advice for improving finance and procurement and saving companies of all sizes time and money. But we’re not the only people with opinions and ideas. We’d love to hear from you so join the conversation!
- June 15, 2017
- Karla Friede
- Finance & AP
Earlier this year, Coupa announced Coupa Payments powered by Nvoicepay. In this article Nvoicepay CEO Karla Friede explains how fintechs are reinventing B2B payments, and why it has been so long in coming.
Accounts payable departments have realized that they need to stop paying suppliers with paper checks and move to electronic payments. While there's intention to head in this direction, most U.S. companies estimate that they are still making about 50 percent of their payments by check. Why is progress so slow?
Electronic payments as we’ve known them for the past few decades are only partially electronic. The payment moves electronically, but there’s still a lot of manual effort on the front end to get the payment ready to go, and on the back end to resolve questions and errors.
The irony is that in moving some payments to card and some to ACH, AP departments have reduced a sliver of costs and inefficiencies, while at the same time introducing new ones. Now instead of one process, AP is juggling three separate processes, each with limited visibility, traceability, and reconciliation information. There’s still a lot of manual effort.
Fintechs are redefining electronic payments by making it possible to make card, ACH, check and even cross-border payments within a single process that requires nothing more to initiate than the standard reports out of the company’s accounting system. Once payment is sent, it’s guaranteed to arrive with no further effort on AP’s part.
Even though these fintech solutions leverage the same payment types banks have offered for decades, they differ in some very important ways that give AP much greater efficiency, visibility, and control.
Riding the rails
What Fintech payment solutions have in common with bank solutions is that they ride on same payment rails. In the world of payments, ‘rails’ refers to the network that transports packets of encoded payment information. All banks use NACHA’s standard for trading ACH files as their rail system. MasterCard/Visa and Amex each have their own rails. All payment “cars" ride these rails in the U.S. Both banks and fintechs use them.
The difference between bank payment solutions and fintech payment solutions is in the cars that ride on these rails. Fintechs are building new rail cars that have much more functionality and better service.
Rumbly old rail cars
It’s the difference between putting your payments in rumbly old rail cars with bench seats and windows that jam, where you hoist your own luggage and bring your own picnic, versus putting them aboard a sleek, modern rail car with air conditioning, wifi, a porter, and gourmet food delivered to your reclining seat.
For example, if you want to send ACH payments through your bank, you have to supply each supplier’s current bank account number, routing number, and remittance address along with the amount of payment in a file to the bank.
The file has to be formatted in a particular way and can’t have any errors in it, or the payment won’t go through. Some banks will accept all payment types (ACH, card, and check) in one file, but that’s not especially helpful because it’s still up to you to indicate what type of payment your supplier accepts.
In any event, each payment type goes across its own set of rails, creating three different processes to manage on the back end. If there's something that goes wrong with a payment, it's hard to reconcile, because neither AP nor anybody at the bank can see across all those payment types in one place.
A fourth process
Cross-border payments through a bank require a fourth, entirely separate process that sits outside the accounting system. You have to hand-key the information in your bank portal and then manually key it back into your accounting system.
There is zero visibility from the moment the payment is sent until you get confirmation of receipt. If something goes wrong, you may not know for days or even weeks later that the payment never arrived. Organizations report that although cross-border payments only account for 20 percent of their payments, managing the process takes up to 80 percent of AP's time.
Breaking the stronghold
Until recently, banks have had a stronghold on payments. The problem is that they haven’t provided any service or updated technology to customers riding these rails. This is why most organizations have only realized a marginal benefit from making electronic payments.
Why haven’t banks invested in better rail cars, or offered services to make the old ones easier to use? Banks are distribution channels, not technology companies. They typically don’t own or build the solutions they sell. Different companies have, over time, provided them with solutions for their customers—everything from check printing to today’s mobile apps. Once a solution gets some traction in the marketplace, banks are willing to add it to their sales strategy, but they don’t own it, so they can't change it or improve it.
Furthermore, when you sign up for a bank payment solution, you might be buying ACH payments from one division of the bank, card payments from another, and check payment processing from yet another. You might even be buying them from three different banks.
Financial technology companies such as Nvoicepay are bringing all payments, including cross-border payments, together in one streamlined, electronic process through a combination of cloud technology, modern APIs and human customer service.
Building a better rail car
APIs are what make it possible for applications to connect with each other, share data, and take certain actions on one another’s behalf. In the on-premise world, business applications were located in an on-site server room, and it was hard to connect systems. Using the cloud, it's easy to use APIs to connect to virtually any system that's already in place in the enterprise.
For example, scanning has been around for at least 20 years. AP workflow has been around for at least 10 years. If you already have those systems in place, you can make an API call and extract invoice and payment information simply with little to no development.
Using different APIs, fintechs bring together the payment rails, the cross-border wire process, and the supplier data in one place. It’s all served up in single interface, in a way that makes sense for someone who’s working through an accounts payable process.
It's one process for all payments—ACH, card, cross-border, and check. There’s no need to assemble specific and detailed payment files. The information can be captured and used within the interface from whichever payment file the accounting system creates. All that must be done by AP is to review the payments file and select "pay".
They can view all payments as they move through the system, all the way to settlement. If they need to track something down, it’s right at their fingertips.
Fintechs are also using cloud technology and people to provide all of the services around supplier payments. They collect, house, and maintain the information required to pay suppliers so AP doesn’t have to. They constantly update the information to ensure the payment goes to the correct spot and that payment is made by the most efficient and cost-effective means. And if anything goes wrong, the payment solution provider's customer support team handles follow up. Delivery of the payment is guaranteed.
Until now, the irony of electronic payments has been that if customers had just stayed on paper, it would have been more efficient because it was one process instead of several. Now it is becoming clear that to scale, to comply with regulation, to become efficient, and move at the pace of the industry, electronic payments are essential.
Fortunately, electronic payments have been reinvented by fintech. With today’s technology, AP no longer needs to know or care how a payment gets made. They only need to know who they want to pay and how much, and then can pay it from a single interface. Efficiency, visibility, traceability, accountability, and data: that’s what electronic payments means today. It’s time to park those rumbly old cars in the rail yard, and put your payments on the fintech bullet train.
Karla Friede is CEO and co-founder of Nvoicepay. She has also held marketing positions at Zevez and GeoTrust, and was co-founder and consultant for the Ascent Group.
- Why using OCR for electronic invoice processing is like hitching a buggy to your horse
March 17, 2014 | by J.R. Robertson | Finance & AP
Optical Character Recognition (OCR) technology is a hardware/software tool that takes a paper document, usually an invoice, scans and “reads” it and turns it into metadata that...
- Winning the hearts and minds of the 99 percenters of B2B: end users
June 12, 2014 | by Gabe Perez | IT & Technology
I walked into a 50,000-person company not too long ago to talk to them about some software for a business process transformation. When I started talking about software...
- Scratching an itch leads to easier expense reports for thousands
January 13, 2014 | by Tony Darugar | Expenses
Earlier this month, we hosted a webinar on managed travel with Charles Bacharach of Orbitz for Business and our own Tony Darugar, Product Manager for Coupa Expenses. Back in...